Personal Lines
Private flood insurance with higher limits and flexible underwriting, an alternative to federal NFIP.
Free Coverage ReviewFinancial Strength
A Excellent
Highest = A++. Fewer than 5% of carriers qualify.
Customer Satisfaction
Flood specialist, outside the standard home insurance study scope.
J.D. Power 2025. Higher score = better customer satisfaction.
Complaint Record
Tracks below the industry average for the specialty segment.
Below 1.0 = fewer complaints than industry average. Lower is better.
Best Fit Profile
Best fit profile
Best Pricing For
Best pricing context
Not a Good Fit For
Not a good fit
Selective Insurance is rated A Excellent by AM Best and writes personal and commercial lines through independent agents. In personal lines, Selective is one of the admitted markets for flood insurance, offering private flood policies that compete with NFIP on price and coverage for preferred-risk properties. They also write standard homeowners and auto.
This is what the claims process actually looks like based on published data and complaint records.
Claims ExperienceEstablished commercial and flood insurance claims infrastructure. Private flood claims often process faster than NFIP due to less bureaucratic process.
Often competitive with NFIP for preferred-risk properties. Can be more expensive than NFIP for high-risk coastal properties where federal subsidies apply. We compare both.
Primary comparison is NFIP (federal flood program). Selective wins on higher limits, private flood for homeowners above NFIP cap, and claims speed. NFIP wins on high-risk coastal properties with subsidized premiums and clients needing basic coverage only.
Do We Work With Them?
Yes
Georgia Appetite
Selective writes Georgia flood broadly. Strong fit for coastal Georgia (Tybee, Savannah, St. Simons), Chattahoochee River floodplain properties, and any Georgia home in FEMA Zone AE where a secured loan requires flood. Also writes Preferred Risk Policies in low-risk zones where homeowners want protection NFIP's limits cannot provide.
Higher dwelling and contents limits than NFIP's $250K/$100K caps
More flexible underwriting than NFIP, faster bind process
Claims process typically faster than NFIP bureaucratic timeline
Pricing not subsidized like NFIP; may be more expensive for true high-risk properties
Single-product carrier for most retail clients; no home or auto option
Not a good fit for
Non-standard risks, older properties, high-value estates, or commercial accounts. Selective focuses on the preferred personal and small commercial standard market.
Prefer to talk it through?
Our team is available Monday to Friday, 9am to 6pm ET.
Still weighing your options?
Upload your current dec page or tell us what you have. We review it free, show you where the gaps are, and tell you what it costs to fix them. No obligation, response within one business day.
Free Coverage Review