When you talk to your claims adjuster, be factual, be brief, and let your documentation do the talking. Adjusters are trained to gather information that supports the carrier's position. Anything you say can shape your payout.
Understand whose side the adjuster is on
The adjuster works for the insurance carrier, not for you. Their job is to investigate the loss, evaluate damage, and recommend a settlement. Most adjusters are fair, but their default position is to pay the minimum that satisfies the policy. They are not your advocate. You have to advocate for yourself, or work with an independent agent who can do it on your behalf.
Stick to facts you observed directly
When asked what happened, describe what you saw. Avoid speculating about cause, fault, pre-existing condition, or anything you did not witness. If you do not know an answer, say so. "I don't know" is a better answer than a guess that gets used against you later.
After a roof leak, a homeowner told the adjuster "I think the storm last week did it." The adjuster pulled weather records showing only minor wind that week and reduced the claim, citing the homeowner's own statement as evidence the damage predated the reported event. A better answer: "We noticed water staining on the ceiling on October 3. I do not know when the leak actually started."
Keep your declarations page in front of you
Your dec page shows your coverage limits, deductibles, and any endorsements. When the adjuster references coverage, reference the dec page back. This keeps the conversation anchored in what your policy actually says, not what the adjuster characterizes it as.
Ask for everything in writing
After every phone conversation, ask the adjuster to email a summary of what was discussed and next steps. If they refuse or forget, send your own summary email and ask them to confirm or correct. Written records prevent later disputes about who said what.
Phrases that can hurt you
Casual remarks become evidence. Avoid: "It is no big deal," "I should have fixed that earlier," "I admit it was my fault," "I am pretty sure the storm in March caused it." Each of these can be used to reduce your settlement. The factual version is fine; the speculative or self-blaming version is not.
When to bring in your agent
If the adjuster proposes a settlement that seems low, asks questions that feel like a trap, or stops responding, involve your independent agent. Agents do not work for the carrier; they advocate for you and can re-open conversations that have stalled. Their involvement often shifts the dynamic without escalating to a complaint or lawsuit.
Stuck on a claim conversation?
If your claim is not moving or the offer does not match your damage, we can help. Send us a description of where things stand and your declarations page. We will tell you whether the carrier is acting reasonably and what to push on next.
Free Coverage Review